5 Terrible Ways to Build Your Talent Pipeline (Please, Don’t Do These)

How Not to Build a Talent Pipeline: 5 Approaches That Will Backfire

When it comes to building a talent pipeline, most people are quick to emphasize what works. But let’s flip that perspective and look at what absolutely doesn’t. Think of these as the mistakes that live in dark corners and can go overlooked, like mismatched socks or expired yogurt, waiting to cause chaos the moment you’re not paying attention. Avoid these approaches at all costs, unless, of course, you’re planning a masterclass in self-sabotage.

1. Posting Job Descriptions That Read Like Legalese

There’s nothing like a wall of dry, jargon-packed text to make a candidate’s eyes glaze over. Phrases like “must have extensive experience in leveraging cross-functional synergy” are about as appealing as boiled broccoli. They’re not inspiring anyone to hit “apply.”

Instead of treating job descriptions as an opportunity to flex your thesaurus, focus on clarity and personality. Be honest about the role, sprinkle in some humanity, and drop the corporate speak.

2. Focusing Exclusively on Active Job Seekers

Imagine fishing in a puddle and wondering why you’re not catching anything. That’s what happens when you limit your recruitment strategy to people actively applying for roles. Sure, there are talented individuals in that group, but they’re not the whole story.

Some of the best candidates are too busy doing excellent work to even glance at a job board. Engaging passive candidates—through networking, targeted outreach, or building relationships on professional platforms—broadens your pool significantly. And let’s face it, most people will take your call if you say something like, “We’ve heard about your amazing work and think you’d be a great fit for something exciting.”

3. Treating Your Candidate Database Like a Time Capsule

Picture this: You’re dusting off a spreadsheet last updated when floppy disks were still a thing. Sound familiar? If it does, and your candidate database feels like a historical artifact, you’re doing it wrong.

Regularly engaging with past candidates is crucial. Whether it’s through newsletters, updates about your company, or even just an occasional check-in, keeping your talent pool warm is a lot easier than starting from scratch every time. Use automation to make this less painful, but keep the messaging personalized. Nobody likes feeling like part of a bulk email blast.

4. Ignoring Employer Branding (or Worse, Getting It Wrong)

Your employer brand is the public face of your recruiting efforts. It’s what candidates see when they Google you or scroll through your company’s social media. If your brand screams “boring,” “toxic,” or “unoriginal,” don’t expect a flood of applications from top talent.

To get it right, start by making sure your values and culture are actually worth promoting. Showcase what makes your workplace unique, whether that’s innovative projects, supportive management, or the office dog named Kevin. Be honest, but don’t oversell—nobody likes being promised a gourmet meal and then being served cold pizza.

5. Overlooking Candidate Experience

Picture this: a candidate applies to your company, waits weeks without hearing anything, and finally gets a “no” via an auto-reply email. What do you think they’re going to tell their friends about your company? Spoiler: nothing good.

Treating candidates like numbers instead of people is a surefire way to tarnish your reputation. A poor candidate experience doesn’t just lose you one potential hire; it can ripple outward to others in their network. Prioritize communication, set realistic expectations, and give constructive feedback wherever possible. Even a rejection can leave a positive impression if handled with respect.

The Bottom Line

Recruitment doesn’t have to feel like never-ending car crash happening in slow motion. By steering clear (no pun intended) of these five pitfalls, you’ll not only improve your talent pipeline but also create a process that feels far more rewarding—for both you and your candidates. And if you’re looking for tools that make this easier, well, we might know a thing or two about that.

To learn more, chat with our experts.

‍